Teen Girl Squad/YMMV
- Non Sequitur Scene: Guaranteed at least one per episode.
- Dude, Not Funny: The series possibly poking fun at a serious subject like anorexia in the Tenth Issueversary's opening scene was risky to say the least.
- Ear Worm:
- "And the chumbly wumbly bear came-a tumblin' down..."
- "I miss video games. I miss my mom. I miss video games. I - I - I miss my mom..."
- Ensemble Darkhorse: The title characters are this within the Homestar Runner body of work.
- Peacy P, y'all biscuitheads!
- Memetic Mutation
- What Do You Mean It's Not for Kids?: While the cartoon it spun off from was a bit tame, despite the occasional risque humor, the Nightmare Fuel, and Late to the Punchline moments, this one isn't, if only for the aforementioned Family-Unfriendly Violence.
- Granted, it's incredibly poorly-drawn Family-Unfriendly Violence, and the ESRB rated the second episode of Strong Bad's Cool Game For Attractive People E10+ despite the inclusion of a make-your-own TGS comic like the first episode, so...
- The Woobie: Given the material, What's-Her-Face has a surprisingly good claim to this. Possibly acknowledged with an even more pointedly cruel scene than usual in #15.